Welfare and Rational Care (Princeton Monographs in by Stephen Darwall

By Stephen Darwall

What form of existence top guarantees human welfare? because the historic Greeks, this query has been as vital to moral philosophy as to boring mirrored image. yet what precisely is welfare? this question has suffered from relative forget. And, as Stephen Darwall exhibits, it has performed so at a cost. featuring a provocative new "rational care conception of welfare," Darwall proves right figuring out of welfare essentially alterations how we expect approximately what's most sensible for people.

Most philosophers have assumed person's welfare is what's reliable from her viewpoint, specifically, what she has a particular cause to pursue. within the now average terminology, welfare is thought to have an "agent-relative normativity." Darwall against this argues that a persons solid is what one may still wish for that individual insofar as one cares for her. Welfare, in different phrases, is normative, yet now not specially for the individual whose welfare is at stake. furthermore, Darwall makes the novel thought that something's contributing to a persons welfare is similar factor as its being whatever one should wish for her personal sake, insofar as one cares. Darwall defends this thought with readability, precision, and style, and with a refined figuring out of where of sympathetic main issue within the wealthy psychology of sympathy and empathy. His forceful arguments will swap how we comprehend an idea significant to ethics and our realizing of human bonds and human choices.

Show description

Read or Download Welfare and Rational Care (Princeton Monographs in Philosophy) PDF

Similar social services & welfare books

Parenting Your Parents: Support Strategies for Meeting the Challenge of Aging in the Family

Whilst our mom and dad achieve a definite age and feature trouble coping, we discover ourselves puzzling over how one can offer them with the type of love, care, help, and a spotlight they wish - simply as they've got performed for us all our lives. Parenting Your mom and dad indicates, via case reviews, that you're not on my own and gives recommendation that can assist you alongside this hard yet profitable trip.

Evaluating Social Work Effectiveness (UK Higher Education OUP Humanities & Social Sciences Health & Social Welfare)

Social paintings has an influence on huge numbers of voters via its prone for kids and households, aged humans, people with psychological or actual illnesses and offenders. It additionally provokes a lot feedback; its effectiveness is puzzled and there are expanding calls for for this to be confirmed.

The Politics of Visual Language: Deafness, Language Choice, and Political Socialization

The Politics of visible Language is an interesting and distinct standpoint most often technique of political socialization; designated simply because past reviews during this box have assumed that each one individuals within the approach can listen. This paintings experiences those that can't listen and, whereas it makes an attempt an neutral review of all academic methodologies, will unquestionably bring up new questions in the Deaf neighborhood and past.

Additional resources for Welfare and Rational Care (Princeton Monographs in Philosophy)

Example text

The care we hope for, from some at least, is sympathy. 16 CHAPTER I This contrast also helps to bring out a tension within the utilitarian tradition. Originally, the claim that morality is a matter of maximizing overall happiness was thought to derive from equal care or benevolence. 25 Usually these views were combined with hedonist theories of welfare. In the last century, however, it became more common to find utilitarianism formulated in terms of preference-satisfaction. Now if I am right about welfare, giving equal weight to each person’s preferences or rational preferences, to what each values or should value, from his point of view, is not what one is led to by caring equally for every person or, perhaps, even more obviously, by caring equally for every sentient creature.

Of course, they very frequently are, but they generate reasons of care only to the extent that they are. Moreover, to one caring, considerations of welfare present themselves as agentneutral, rather than agent-relative. From the perspective of sympathetic concern, what benefits the cared for seems not only good for him; it seems a good thing absolutely (agent-neutrally) that he benefited in this way. Think of a parent’s relation to his child at different stages of life. A toddler’s desires and will give normative reasons to a parent just insofar as they indicate or represent what is for the child’s good.

A rational care theory of welfare does not, of course, hold that someone who cares for another can simply make it true that something is for that person’s good just by desiring it for him for his sake. In order for a thing to be in a person’s interest it must be something someone who cared about the person would rationally want for him for his sake. Rational care theories can be neutral on which theory of rationality and rational desire is correct, but they must hold that there being nonrelative facts about welfare depend on there being facts about what anyone who cares for that person would rationally want for him, insofar as she cares.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.70 of 5 – based on 15 votes